A Shift in Perspective – It’s Not About “Fixing” Your Dog
Written by Lauren Tsao, MS, CDBC, CPDT-KA
Photo shows two dog playing.
Many dog owners often approach training and behavior with the hope of “fixing” certain problems. But what if we changed focus from complete solutions to realistic, achievable progress? This shift in mindset is essential when dealing with challenging behaviors like aggression, resource guarding, or ingrained habits that may have been developing for years. Particularly when problems have had time to intensify or become routine, the goal should be gradual improvement, not a quick fix.
Training isn’t about perfection. It’s about meeting our dogs where they are, understanding their limits, and celebrating each small step toward a better relationship. Today, we’ll explore why behavior change is a gradual process and how setting realistic goals can lead to lasting, meaningful progress.
Why “Fixing” Isn’t the Right Goal
Behavior change, especially in complex cases, takes time, patience, and a commitment to consistent effort. When we view training as a “fix” for our dogs, we risk setting unrealistic expectations and becoming discouraged when we don’t see immediate results. Here’s why aiming to “fix” your dog’s behavior can often lead to setbacks rather than sustainable success:
Rehearsed Behaviors Are Deeply Rooted: Just as humans don’t break old habits overnight, dogs require time and reinforcement to unlearn certain behaviors. Behaviors like aggression, fear, and reactivity often have a long reinforcement history. Every time a dog acts aggressively or reacts out of fear, they are practicing that behavior and further reinforcing it. For example, a dog that has had multiple negative experiences with strangers may have developed a deeply ingrained reaction to bark, growl, or lunge whenever they feel threatened. Rehearsed behaviors are habitual and can take weeks, months, or even years of careful retraining to transform, particularly if these behaviors have been a part of their routine for a long time.
Single Classes or Short Programs Aren’t Magic Solutions: A one-time group class or a standard six-week training program is typically just a starting point for dogs dealing with complex issues like reactivity or aggression. While these programs can introduce useful skills and techniques, they often aren’t enough to address deep-rooted behavioral challenges. The reality is that behavior modification, especially for more severe issues, requires ongoing support and regular practice to maintain progress. For example, a dog with a history of multiple dog fights will need more than basic obedience training to improve; they need a structured, long-term plan that addresses triggers, reinforces positive behaviors, and gradually builds their tolerance. Owners should expect to invest time in ongoing reinforcement and management even after the initial training period.
Owners should also beware if they are being offer or “guaranteed” fix quicks by trainers for complex concerns. Behavior of another animal can never be ethically guaranteed. Trainer “guarantees” can create a false sense of comfort, which can be dangerous if you own a dog with a bite or dog fight history and are thus not permitted by many organizations for dog trainers.Behavioral Challenges Are Multifaceted: Dogs are complex beings. Their behaviors are influenced by a combination of genetics, environment, life experiences, and current relationships. Behavior can also be influence by the dog’s medical condition. Behavior challenges don’t stem from a single source, nor are they resolved by a one-size-fits-all approach. For example, a dog’s fear of strangers may be influenced by a traumatic past experience, limited socialization as a puppy, or an inherited tendency toward cautiousness. Additionally, a dog’s environment and routine, as well as the relationship they have with their owner, all play a role in shaping behavior. Attempting to “fix” a behavior without considering these underlying factors can lead to temporary or superficial changes that don’t address the root cause, ultimately hindering progress.
Dogs Have Unique Limits and Learning Curves: Like people, dogs have individual learning curves, and some behaviors take longer to modify than others. Expecting a total “fix” in a short time frame can create pressure on both the dog and yourself. This can lead to frustration and feelings of failure when progress doesn’t happen immediately. A shy, anxious dog might never become a social butterfly, and that’s okay. Shifting the goal to focus on manageable progress, like calmly tolerating visitors or walking without reacting to every dog they see, is more realistic and supportive of the dog’s individual journey.
The Value of Achievable Dog Training Goals
Instead of striving for a “fixed” dog, try focusing on achievable, specific goals. Shifting your mindset to emphasize progress, rather than perfection, helps you and your dog experience more joy in each step forward. Celebrating each small improvement, rather than waiting for total transformation, brings positive reinforcement to both you and your dog. Here’s why taking small steps matters and can lead to a stronger, happier bond:
Small Wins Build Confidence: Both dogs and their owners benefit from small, attainable goals. For your dog, each small success, whether it’s staying calm when a visitor arrives or managing a few seconds of loose-leash walking, reinforces desirable behavior working training with positive reinforcement based methods.It also provides a moment of clarity that good things happen when they stay calm or follow your cues. For you, each win builds confidence in your ability to work with your dog. These moments can be a powerful reminder of your shared progress. Instead of getting discouraged by the challenges, you’re encouraged by each step forward, which helps you and your dog stay motivated to keep going.
Realistic Goals Prevent Frustration: Setting overly ambitious goals, like expecting a reactive dog to stay calm around other dogs immediately, can quickly lead to frustration and burnout. Unrealistic expectations can make every setback feel like a failure. Instead, aim for goals that are achievable in the short term. For example, if your dog barks at strangers, start with a goal of ability to leave the situation if your dog become fixated or finding a safe distance where your dog doesn’t bark, so they no longer rehearse the behavior. This shifts the focus from expecting a complete change to recognizing gradual improvements. These more manageable goals are not only motivating, but allow for sustainable progress over time.
Progress, Not Perfection, Helps Owners Stay Engaged: It’s easy to lose motivation if you’re always aiming for an end goal that feels far away, especially if progress seems slow. But when you focus on small, reachable goals, training feels more manageable and enjoyable. It gives you a sense of accomplishment that keeps you engaged in your dog’s development. This approach encourages you to see progress as a journey, where each step, no matter how small, is meaningful. Training sessions become a positive experience rather than a pressure to “fix” things all at once. This means you’re more likely to stay consistent and motivated.
Photo shows dog running with lake and mountains in background.
Proactive vs. Reactive: The Importance of Early Training and Intervention
When behavioral issues go unaddressed, they often become more challenging to manage. That’s why it’s so valuable to take a proactive approach. Training isn’t something we do only after problems arise. It’s part of a lifelong process of supporting our dog’s well-being. Here’s why addressing behavior early on is essential:
Early Intervention Helps Prevent Escalation: Many behaviors are more manageable when addressed early. By tackling signs of fear, anxiety, or aggression as soon as they appear, you can prevent these issues from becoming ingrained.
Ongoing Training Builds a Strong Foundation: Proactive training helps set up a solid foundation, making it easier to handle future challenges. Even simple cues like “come,” “stay,” and “leave it” build communication and trust between you and your dog.
Understanding Behavior as Part of Dog Ownership: Training isn’t a one-time fix; it’s a continuous process. When we bring a dog into our lives, we commit to their ongoing development, just as we do with our own growth and learning. Recognizing training as an essential aspect of dog ownership helps normalize the idea that support isn’t optional, it’s part of a loving, responsible relationship.
Photo shows dog laying down.
Embracing a Lifelong Journey with Your Dog
When we embrace training as a long-term journey, rather than a quick solution, it changes our expectations in positive ways. Instead of focusing on “fixing” your dog, try to appreciate the process of helping them learn, grow, and adapt. This approach helps us to become patient, compassionate partners in their journey, no matter the challenges. It’s normal to feel discouraged when progress seems slow. Remember, each small step you achieve together is meaningful. Every bit of progress brings you closer to a happier, more harmonious relationship with your dog.
If you’re ready to support your dog’s behavior in a compassionate, step-by-step way, reach out for professional guidance. As a certified trainer, I work with dog owners around the world virtual and in-person in Jackson, MS to create realistic goals and sustainable progress plans that respect your dog’s unique needs. Let’s take that journey together by reading more about how I can help you!
Disclaimer: I am a professional dog trainer and certified dog behavior consultant, but I am not a veterinarian. The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended to be a substitute for professional veterinary advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult with a qualified veterinarian regarding any medical concerns you may have about your dog’s health. If you suspect your dog is in pain or experiencing discomfort, seek the guidance of a licensed veterinary professional for proper assessment and treatment. Never disregard or delay seeking veterinary advice.
